Movie remakes tend to be a mixed bag. On one end of the spectrum, you have something that exceeds expectations like the rebooted Star Trek series (2009-present) – and then you have the disaster of a monster-lizard fest that was 1998’s Godzilla.

This year’s It was something that straddled the fine line between a good reboot & a bad one – so instead of separate lists of good & bad things about the movie, here’s a combined list that shows both sides of every point:

Or you could just skip to the end for the score we’re giving it, and a brief explanation as to why.


(we tried to make it spoiler-free as possible)


Pennywise the Dancing Clown

The Good: Bill Skarsgård’s performance as Pennywise the Dancing Clown was absolutely terrifying to watch, and I mean Heath Ledger’s Joker levels of terrifying. Skarsgård nailed the performance, as I constantly got a vibe that was equal parts terrifying, menacing, sinister, and “something’s seriously wrong with this guy” every time Pennywise appeared on screen – I personally feel he took some body posture cues from Death Note’s Ryuk for added emphasis.

The Bad: Pennywise the Dancing Clown was only terrifying for the first two-thirds of the movie, before It devolved into a typical modern horror movie with an overly-elaborate CGI monster.

The Plot

Photo Credit: A fan-made poster for the upcoming film by Smalltownhero on Deviant Art

The Good: It didn’t deviate too much from the original’s plot – movie purists rejoice!

The Bad: It didn’t deviate enough from the original’s plot, so the movie is largely predictable for people who have watched the original. Also, the way the plot is structured leaves room for quite a few plot holes.


How the children “defeat” Pennywise

The Good: In the original, the children “defeat” Pennywise by using the power of imagination. In the 2017 remake, they do so by overcoming their fear – which honestly makes a lot more sense than the original.

The Bad: While the children “defeating” Pennywise by overcoming their fear is extremely clichéd, this removed a key aspect of the original that I enjoyed – the imagination of children. Pennywise is practically invisible to adults & doesn’t affect or attack them at all because he plays & preys on the imagination of children. Removing this aspect from It raises the question “What stops Pennywise from attacking the adults?”.

The explanation for the movie’s catchphrase “You’ll Float Too”

The Good: The 2017 version if It had a far creepier explanation for “You’ll Float Too” than the original.

The Bad: The 2017 version of It left results of the explanation and the film’s climax…unaddressed. Not unexplained, but unaddressed. The main characters literally walked away from the issue after the film’s climax without ever addressing it.

2017’s It is dark, as in really dark – in more ways than one.

The Good: In the original, Beverley’s father is shown as being abusive – slapping and beating her on-screen during the movie. In the 2017 remake, no such violence is shown…but something far darker and sinister is implied.

The Bad: The lighting is unrealistically dark in some scenes, which kind of broke my immersion from time to time. Were people not able to afford to turn on the lights in their houses in 1989 (when the movie was set), or did they straight up just not know how to open windows/curtains/blinds?



Overall, I give the It a solid 6.5/10. While Bill Skarsgård’s portrayal of Pennywise the Clown was terrifyingly brilliant, it wasn’t enough to save the It from falling into the same hole that many remakes and modern movies do. The plot was close enough to the original that it wouldn’t anger fans of the original, but a little too close to the point that large parts of the movie ended up predictable. However, plot holes aside, the makers of the 2017 remake managed to make the It far darker and sinister than its 1990 predecessor – and deserves a spot on my list of must-watch Horror Movies of 2017.

Most Memorable Moments in MCU (In no particular order)

By Norain F. 10 years and 18 movies, with many more to be released in the future, Marvel Cinematic Universe is definitely one of the biggest film franchises in Hollywood. I have a confession. I was a little too late on the Marvel movies bandwagon. I never...

REVIEW: The Rock’s Rampage is good, pointless fun.

By Faris Foat Rampage has landed in cinema yesterday. Heavily based on the 1986 arcade game under the same name, Rampage adopts a simple plot and something you’ve probably heard before: science experiment gone wrong, an MNC wanting to make money out of it,...

10 years of MCU: The Best Movies Ranked

Marvel has created many ‘Marvel-lous’ movies the last decade, creating a cultural phenomenon that’s injected life back into a limp blockbuster scene. Ranging from the first MCU (Marvel Cinematic Universe) movie, Iron Man, to the new Black Panther movie, 18...

REVIEW: Dukun bukanlah filem yang kita jangkakan

By Faris Foat Anda mungkin kenal beliau dari Bunohan, dan Interchange tetapi Dain Said juga merupakan pengarah filem kontroversi, Dukun pada tahun 2007. Dikatakan mengambil inspirasi daripada kes pembunuhan ahli politik yang menggemparkan Malaysia suatu...

Marvel TV heroes that are likely to appear in the MCU after Infinity War

By Faris Foat Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) is expanding and the heroes from the TV universe are not left behind. Since the debut of the ABC Studios’ Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D (AoS) in 2013 and the emergence of Netflix’s Daredevil in 2015, Marvel TV universe...

Die as Green Ranger, or live long enough and become Lord Drakkon

By Faris Foat David Frank startled the fans with his surprising return as the older Green Ranger gone bad, Lord Drakken and he intends to destroy all the rangers. Fans will see all the rangers coming together in this crossover story event. The synopsis for...

6 reasons why Pacific Rim: Uprising should have been named “Giant Robots vs Aliens: A Generic Hollywood Blockbuster”

Pacific Rim: Uprising, the highly anticipated sequel to 2013’s Pacific Rim, hits cinemas around the world this week. Set 10 years after the events of the original movie, Uprising features an all-new cast, with only 3 familiar names returning from the...

Here’s the full list of 2018 Oscar winners!

By Shazwan Zulkiffli It’s that time of the year again where top Hollywood industry leaders gather under one roof with all their glam, bling and sparkle to celebrate the best productions of the year. 2017 was a year packed with critically acclaimed films...

Mark Hamill, Margot Robbie, Chadwick Boseman, and more hit the Red Carpet at the 2018 Oscars!

The 90th Academy Awards, or better known to us millennials as the 2018 Oscars, is well underway! With a slew of exciting films slated for awards, the red carpet was filled with Hollywood's cream of the crop in attendance for the biggest night in the film...

Movie Review: Black Panther (No Spoilers)

With much hype, Marvel’s Black Panther has finally arrived in cinemas to an overwhelming amount of critical acclaim. The last movie in the MCU’s Phase 3 before the start of Avengers: Infinity War, this movie proves that the genre of comic book heroes can...

Clarks Unveils Black Panther Inspired Trigenic Evo

WAIT WHAT Dude. Clarks, the shoes that your parents buy, those Clarks, have come out with a kicker of its own. The Trigenic Evo silhouette gets a redesign inspired by Marvel’s hotly anticipated movie, Black Panther. Keeping in line with Black Panther’s...

Don’t Let the Ringgit Shrink, Downsize Yourself Instead!

The big life is a small step away. Let no one tell you any different - times are hard. The ringgit doesn’t go quite as far as it once did, and even nasi lemak is going up in price these days. Let’s not even get started on portion sizes - we Malaysians love...